Emi and Matt logo Emi and MattA home for two
Kitchen Notes

Yellow Sticker Shopping for Two and What Is Worth It

Last March I added a column to the shared spreadsheet called "reduced" and started logging every yellow sticker item we bought, what it cost, what it would have cost, and whether we actually ate it.

Reduced price meat and cheese with yellow stickers laid out on a small kitchen worktop beside freezer bags and a marker pen

Last March I added a column to the shared spreadsheet called "reduced" and started logging every yellow sticker item we bought, what it cost, what it would have cost, and whether we actually ate it. Twelve months later the saving column said 312.40 pounds. The wasted column said 61.80 pounds. I had expected the first number and I had quietly been hoping the second one would not exist.

That 61.80 is the honest part of this. It is four bags of spinach, a pack of raw prawns we forgot about, two reduced pizzas we did not want by the time Thursday came, and a tray of chicken thighs that went into the freezer in a supermarket bag and came out six months later with the surface dried white. None of that was bad luck. All of it came from buying because of the sticker rather than because of a meal.

When the stickers actually go on

This is the thing nobody tells you, and it is store specific rather than chain specific. The schedule depends on when the shop closes and when their fresh delivery lands, so the pattern at a city centre branch is nothing like the pattern at a big edge of town store.

Our three nearest shops, timed over about forty visits. The small high street supermarket that shuts at 23:00 does a first pass at roughly 17:30 at 30 percent off, a second at 20:00 at 50 percent, and a final sweep around 21:45 where things drop to 10p and 20p. The large store that shuts at 22:00 does its serious reductions between 19:00 and 19:30 and there is very little left after 20:00 because the staff there buy it themselves, which is fair enough. The discounter two streets away does one pass in the morning, around 08:15, and nothing in the evening at all.

The last sweep sounds like the obvious one to target and it is the worst value for two people. At 21:45 what remains is bakery, bagged salad, and sandwiches, which is the category that keeps the shortest and fits a two person week the least. The 19:00 to 20:00 window at the bigger store is where the meat and fish appear, and meat is the only category where the saving is large enough to change a monthly food budget.

Odalys makes one point here that I resisted for a long time. Going out specially is a loss. A 25 minute return walk to maybe find something is not free, and twice we have come home with 4 pounds of reduced food and then ordered a takeaway because it was half nine and neither of us wanted to cook. Reduced shopping works as an add-on to a trip you were making anyway.

What the spreadsheet says, by category

Twelve months, 148 reduced items between us. I have grouped them by what they were and whether they got eaten.

CategoryItems boughtSavedBinnedVerdict
Meat and fish39168.20 pounds11.40 poundsWorth planning around
Hard cheese and butter1431.10 pounds0Freezes well, always buy
Bread and bakery2218.60 pounds4.20 poundsOnly if it goes in the freezer that night
Bagged salad and spinach1814.30 pounds21.70 poundsA net loss for us
Ready meals and pizza1622.40 pounds13.80 poundsOnly buy what you would pay full price for
Milk, cream, yoghurt2126.80 pounds6.90 poundsFine, cream freezes for cooking
Fruit and veg loose1831.00 pounds3.80 poundsGood if it is going in a soup

The salad row is the one that changed our behaviour. We lost money on bagged leaves across the whole year. Reduced spinach is reduced because it is already two days from collapse, a 200g bag is more than two people eat before it turns, and nobody wants a wilting salad on the one evening they are tired. We stopped buying it entirely in September and the waste column has barely moved since.

Meat at 168 pounds saved is doing almost all of the work. Three quarters of that came from eight or nine good finds: a 6 pound leg of lamb for 2.40, salmon fillets at 1.10 each, a 1.2 kilogram pork shoulder for 3.00. Those are the nights worth having a freezer gap for.

Why "just freeze it" is bad advice in a small flat

Every article on this says the same thing: buy it, freeze it, you cannot lose. In a flat with a fridge freezer and three drawers, that advice is wrong, and it took me about eight months to admit it.

Our freezer holds roughly 24 usable portions. It already carries batch cooked meals, bread, frozen peas, and the stock bag. Every reduced item that goes in displaces something we chose deliberately. Twice I filled a drawer with cheap chicken and we then had no room for the soup we had cooked on Sunday, which went in the fridge and got eaten in four days instead of being spread over three weeks. The chicken did not save money. It moved money from one column to another and cost us a Sunday's work. The way we actually keep the freezer useful is set out in our freezer habits.

There is a second problem, which is quality. Supermarket meat frozen in its own tray at the back of a domestic freezer loses noticeably by week ten. It is not unsafe, it is just dull, and dull food gets eaten reluctantly. If you want reduced meat to be worth it, it has to come out of the tray, go into a bag with the air pressed out, get a date on it in marker, and get used inside two months. That is five minutes of work per pack, and if you are not going to do the five minutes, do not buy the pack.

So our rule now is a number rather than a principle. Four freezer slots are reserved for reduced finds. If they are full, we walk past the trolley. That one rule took our waste from about 7 pounds a month to under 2.

The three rules we ended up with

Buy ingredients, not dinners. A reduced pork shoulder becomes four meals we chose. A reduced lasagne becomes one meal somebody has to want on a specific Tuesday. The first is a saving, the second is a gamble on our own mood.

Apply the full price test. Ask whether you would buy this item at full price in a normal week. If the honest answer is no, the discount is not a discount, it is a 1.20 pound purchase you would not otherwise have made. Roughly a third of our wasted total failed this test.

Repack the same evening, before anything else. Not after dinner, not tomorrow. Bag it, flatten it, date it. The tray of chicken thighs I mentioned at the start went in as it was, and that is the only reason it got thrown away. The wider version of this shows up in how we handle cooking for two without the waste.

One thing to try this month

Pick your usual shop and find out its reduction times, which takes two trips and one conversation with whoever is doing the stickering. They will tell you. Then only shop that window, only for meat, cheese and butter, and only up to four freezer slots.

Log it for a month. Two columns, what you saved and what you binned. If the second column is more than a fifth of the first, the problem is not the shop or the schedule. It is that the sticker is choosing your meals. Our wider food spending figures sit in the food budget for two.

FAQ

Is reduced food safe after the use by date?

Use by is a safety date and we do not push it on meat, fish or dairy. Best before is a quality date and we ignore it routinely on hard cheese, bread and dry goods. Freezing on the use by date stops the clock, which is the whole trick.

Which reduced items freeze worst?

Anything with a high water content and a crisp texture. Bagged salad, cucumber, strawberries and new potatoes all come out of the freezer as something you will not want. Cream splits but is fine stirred into a sauce.

Do the supermarket apps show reductions?

Some show a yellow label in the app for larger stores, usually a few minutes behind the shelf. In our experience the app is useful for checking whether it is worth walking over, and useless for knowing what will still be there.

Is yellow sticker shopping worth it for only two people?

Our figure was about 250 pounds net over a year, so roughly 10 pounds a week, which is real but not transformative. The gain comes almost entirely from meat and cheese, so a household that eats little of either should expect much less.

BK
Bastian Kellerman

Bastian has logged every shared household expense in one spreadsheet since the first month he and Odalys moved in together.

More posts by Bastian

More in Kitchen Notes

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto